These reviews were left by users who have played the game. If you'd like to leave a review, you can start by going to the game page.
Streamlined Age of Steam with more tough decisions because of the split Income/VP track. Being able to use an entire delivery to increase the income makes it less brutal, but it works well. Map looks nice, great bits, and I like the new City Growth rules that replace the randomness of the former Production action in AoS. I still like AoS, but I definitely I prefer Steam. The Standard version is best, but I like that the Base game is an option if I want to teach newbies or want to get in a quicker game. To me, it's more strategic than AoS, because I don't have to worry so much about bankruptcy in the beginning, and I can focus on long-term shipping possibilities, rather than "where am I going to find something to ship *this turn* in order to keep from losing VPs?" I can employ a much more aggressive strategy in Steam than was possible in AoS. Steam eliminates the randomness and some of the brutality (not all!) to make for an overall more enjoyable gaming experience.
after one play i have to say i think this game works really well. i have trouble with the bland art work that would have been great in 1985.. but it's way to insipid for the naughties.. too many hard to read images.. too PC processed... get an artist to work on this.. the dude who did Powergrid would be awesome for this.But the game is great!!
Of AoS, Railroad Tycoon, and Steam, Steam is my preferred version. It has tight money management, but doesn't feel so merciless and cruel. The ridiculous production chart is also gone, and good riddance.
This is an interesting take on the Age of Steam idea. Personally, I don't mind it, though I can easily see how very hard-core AoS players will despise the "resources from heaven" abundance which is lacking in its economically brutal counterpart.
I'm sorry Mr. Wallace, but I probably wont buy it: I already have the lighter (RRT) and meatier version of the game (AoS). edit after Essen 09: but if you get your hands on the special edition and you get the author to sign it, then that's a different story... :p
Two games, three years apart. I don't think I got a good handle on what is involved in the game, and which of the abilities would be most useful when definitely escaped me. But I'll play again and probably feel confused for at least half the game.
Steam, while mechanically sound, fails to maintain thematic continuity and becomes disjointed. What begins as a gratifying race for key routes and city access devolves into a competition for creating the most convoluted delivery routes. The game rewards players for delivering through as many towns as possible, which is antithetical to how a delivery corps should function. In reality short and quick deliveries are preferred, but in Steam players must create an increasingly serpentine web of rail lines. This inconsistency makes the game frustratingly counterintuitive and produces a strong enough disconnect between the theme and mechanics, that makes even the most mechanics-first gamers cringe.