Every..single...day...for a year. One thing to consider is I might hate the game after a year. Wingspan I play a lot anyway, so that's in the running. Gloomhaven? Let's say Gloomhaven you have to throw out....I feel like that one ruins the question. So no Gloomhaven because that's an easy choice. No D&D or Warhammer either...has to be a more standard board game.
So looking over my list Spirit Island, Robinson Crusoe, and Tapestry jump out with Anachrony and Scythe contending. I think Robinson Crusoe might offer the most diversity and scenario selection. Spirit Island has quite a bit of variability as well given the various spirits.
I think in the end I'd go #1 Wingspan, #2 Robinson Crusoe, #3 Spirit Island