My Top 5 Games I wanted to love but don't

Sometimes someone describes a game to you and it sounds amazing, you are all psyched up to play it and then it just falls a little flat, this is not necessarily a list of games I think are bad, just that they weren't as good as I was hoping:

5) #Hyperborea - when one of my game club pulled this out and started explaining I was pretty excited: a bag building-worker placement hybrid with area control and engine building thrown in for good measure. Each faction had a slight assymmetry and there were multiple routes to scoring VP, it sounded like a great experience. However, this was definitely a lesson for me in 'less is more': While all of the ideas in this game were good, and all of them were well executed, none of them were brilliantly executed, no one aspect of the game really sang to me. It was all okay, and while I had a good time with it, it's not a game I am desperate to play again. I am not arrogant enough to say how this problem could be fixed and I think there is some great design hidden in this game, but under just too many layers.

4) #Photosynthesis - I really loved the sound of this game, it had a novel theme and the mechanics were seemingly integrated beautifully into that theme. The sun moving around the board with taller trees blocking smaller ones was excellent and easy to keep track of. However, while I think all this design is smart and elegant, something just didn't quite work for me about it. I think there felt like wasn't a tonne of progression and while it was an enjoyable puzzle it didn't feel particularly satisfying. That said the art design and the little cardboard trees are gorgeous.

3) #Star Wars: Outer Rim - One of talked about a fair bit on this site. I really like Star Wars as a them, I think it is a wonderful universe to explore and was pretty excited about a game happening on the periphery of this huge galactic conflict. That you were living  in the rough and tumble on the edge of the galaxy. However, this game, while being an enjoyable puzzle never really made me feel like I was living dangerously, it was all very calculated and the missions seemed to just be, go here, roll some dice, maybe get some money/points without and real flavour to them. I think maybe with a different theme or expectations I might have enjoyed it more. I was ready to be Boba Fet or Greedo and just never really felt it. May need to play it more as I think it is a well put together game.

2) #Dinosaur Island - Dang, do I love the theme and artwork of this game, getting to create and run a dinopark, and the dino meeples are adorable. However, fo a game about dinosaurs it really didn't feel too dinosaury. 3/4 of the sections of the game could be reskinned to almost any other theme without issue. The actual placing and managing of the dinosaurs (and occaisionally eating customers) was fun in principle but boiled down to just matching two numbers with relatively minor consequences for rampaging dinosaurs. Overall, while none of it was bad, it just didn't really pop in any way.

1) #Marvel Champions: The Card Game - I was really keen to play this when a friend told me his copy had arrived (I even passed up trying out Dune at our games club to give it a go) and from the description thought it sounded great. However, it never really clicked in any way for me. I appreciated them trying to mix up how the heroes worked to add variety but it all just felt a little too mechanical and I never got the feeling that I was a super hero battling some villian bent on destruction. It quickly became a focus on numbers and the actions and characters faded into the background. That may very well just be my issue (which seems to be the case) but I do love trying to get into the narrative/story of the game and this just didn't scratch that itch. Also, the ending felt very anticlimactic, we all calculated our max damage and upon realising that we could do enough, just did that and won. There was no tension or even a feeling of triumph. So not a bad game, but not one I would invest in.

Again, while I don't think any of these games are bad as such, and some of them I should probably play more before disparaging them, they are games that filled me with excitement and were then just mostly okay. Would love to hear other opinions about them or games that didn't measure up for you

Please log in or make an account to post a comment.

3 months ago

Dang, that's too bad. I'm at least mildly interested in all of your 1-4. Sorry they haven't worked out for you. I have seen mixed reviews about Outer Rim. I know some people on here love it, but some of the video reviews I watched were kinda meh on it.

3 months ago

None of them were terrible games, all had enough going for them that I want to try them again. If there is one that really sounds like something you will enjoy then don't let this stop you. I tihnk in most all of these games there were people around the table who had really positive takeaways. 

3 months ago

Yeah I definitely still want to try them all! They were all kind of on the line of interested but not quite sold, so I doubt I'll purchase them unless I come across a great deal, but I'd love to give them all a try one day. I do actually have a friend who owns #Photosynthesis, so one day I'm sure I can try that.

3 months ago

Nice, if and as you play these games would love to hear your take on them.

Supporter3 months ago

Great idea for a list.

I think you should try Outer Rim some more. I definitely think it has that Star Wars feel and perhaps it's better than you are remembering. But I need to remember that not everyone will love all the same games that I do...


3 months ago

True, but it can definitely be the case that a game grows on you as you play it more (and vice versa). I know I didn't think much of #Coup the first time I played it but now it is one of my favourite quick group games. 

3 months ago

And again, it's not at all that I think it is bad, I for sure enjoyed playing it. It was just not great and seemed to miss the mark. However, when board game club resumes I am sure I will play it again.

Linked Games
Star Wars: Outer Rim
Dinosaur Island
Marvel Champions: The Card Game
Linked Topic