Forum | Board Game Atlas

New to Me Games Rankings - March 2023

by cbrady748 | updated 22 hours ago

Doing this early again, I know, but I don't expect to play any games tomorrow much less a new one lol.

March was interesting as I was able to get a lot of plays in of both new games and old favorites alike. I played a total of 10 new to me games in March! Unlike past months, I've actually played a few of these more than my usual once. I might wind up using PubMeeple to help rank them, but I don't know if I'll need it. Here goes nothing!

#Baseball Highlights: 2045 (7 plays) - This game is awesome! And it only cost me $5?! What the heck?! Initial rating = 9/10
#Sheepland (2 plays) - This was a tough call, but I think it's the right one. The problem is not so much that I didn't enjoy any of these games, but more so that none of them jumped out above the others. Basically a stock game where you're trying to collect land tiles where there are the most sheep. Initial rating = 7.5/10
#Akropolis (1 play) - Barely edging out the next game only because Sarah played it with me and I'm positive I could get her to play it again. Initial rating = 7/10
#Blue Moon City (1 play) - Might be a little biased here as I JUST played this 2 days ago, but this game was a lot of fun. A lot of stress, but a lot of fun haha. Initial rating = 7/10
#The Bloody Inn (3 plays) - The theme on this game is absolutely hilarious. You're running a hotel where the guests check in, but might not check out haha. If I had only played solo, this would be higher up this list, but the multiplayer game was a bit too chaotic, at least at 4 players. Initial rating = 7/10
#Mamma Mia (1 play) - Possibly elevated by the stupid jokes and terrible accents my friend and developed while playing. We played wrong though so there may be more to this than meets the eye. Initial rating = 6.5/10
#Was sticht? (1 play) - For how much I think about this game, it should be higher up than this. That being said, it's too long for a trick taking game and our game wasn't even THAT long. If you aren't hitting your goal tiles, it could run on forever. Initial rating = 6.5/10
#Meadow (1 play) - I wasn't exactly blown away by this. I think it's also a bit too long and you can really stall if you've got some unlucky card draws. Initial rating = 6/10
#Bullfrogs (1 play) - Until today, there was no doubt in my mind about what game would end up as the "worst" new to me game in March. This gave me a run for my money lol. I'm giving it the benefit of the doubt because I played with a solo variant. Don't get me wrong, I would (and will) play again, but multiplayer this would be way more fun. Initial rating = 5/10
#The Isle of Cats (2 plays) - I literally only play this because my coworkers want to. Initial rating = 4/10

And that's that! This month kind of reminds me of December last year where I only really played one game that I felt was great and the rest were just good. That being said, a 7/10 (rounded up) is nothing to sneeze at for 5 games out of 10. The good news here is I don't own the worst game I played in March lol.

See Comments

Shelf of Shame Contest 2023 - Q1 Wrap Up

by cbrady748 | updated 5 hours ago

4 | 5 comments | [+]

Incoming stream of posts alert lol. My shelf of shame/opportunity contest has been a success for the most part so far. I played all 14 new to me games I wanted to get played in addition to the 5 games I was trying to play again for one reason or another. The only bad thing was me losing the other contest for not buying games lead me to splurge quite a bit (a month later than @R0land1199 predicted :P). Originally, I was going to try to incorporate some of those newly purchased games into this SoS thing the same way I curated my initial list. I basically had sorted games by weight and tried to evenly distribute them into each quarter of the year. Instead, I got lazy and just decided what I played would get tacked onto this quarter and what I didn't play would get sorted out later. As a spoiler alert, I added a whopping 27 games to my collection between February and March, 23 of which are currently in my possession and can therefore be played. One of them is a KS game that won't arrive forever. This means I would roughly have to play 7 additional games to me every quarter (oof). And looking at what I have played/sold, I actually did it for this quarter!

SoS Games Played

#Aquasphere - Easily the weirdest Feld game I've played to this point. I'm eager to try it again, though it might take some convincing Sarah, especially since we'd have to relearn the rules.
#Meadow - An okay experience that seemed to hit with the wife more than me. I would try it again.
#Was sticht? - I waffle back and forth on if I should keep this game. It was SUPER interesting, but I think takes way too long for a trick taker.

Non-SoS Games Played

#Cavum - Really happy I got around to playing this again. I included in on this list as the game I played for the first time last year that I wanted to play again. I tried picking games that I wouldn't necessarily get to without some added motivation. Meaning this was a game I was excited about, but would find difficult to get played over other games in my collection.
#Concordia - Ended up playing this with just Sarah and myself despite my desire to play it with at least one other person to test out if Sarah would still enjoy it. Really awesome game.
#Escape: The Curse of the Temple - Played this one twice back to back a couple weeks ago with some friends. I already sold it off.

Other New to Me Games Played/Sold

#Akropolis - Mainly picked this up with Sarah in mind and it did not disappoint. Probably more fun for her than me, but as with Meadow, I'm down to play it more.
#Baseball Highlights: 2045 - Spring Training - My most played game of the quarter by far. This game quickly shot up into the upper echelon of my top games.
#Blue Moon City - Played this just a couple days ago with a friend. Really tight race style game that relies on a little bit of luck and careful manuvering. Really enjoyed this one.
#The Bloody Inn - Got in my first multiplayer game of this recently and it was MUCH different than my solo games. I'm not used to having friends apparently lol.
#Bridge City Poker - Took advantage of the KS delivering to get some people with FOMO to buy this off of me. I bought it from someone who lost the rulebook, and it felt like such a chore to have to look them up just to try it out (silly I know).
#Bullfrogs - Bought this on a whim and just played it today actually. It's less mean than I thought it would be, but I think my friend who likes to play games pretty competitively will still enjoy it.
#Homebrewers - Had this slotted to be played I want to say in quarter 3? Anyway I traded for it thinking my brother would enjoy the theme. I just gave it to him to save me the shelf space.
#Mamma Mia - Found out after I played that we played wrong so I guess I'm going to have to play again. Mamma mia! :D
#Sheepland - Got in another play of this and liked it much better than I did the first time. I think it's a keeper.

Going forward, I'm going to attempt to not buy games (unlikely) and sell more often than I do. Despite all my progress playing games, my original list of games was 56 deep and I currently have 56 games still unplayed lol. I'm going to post my initial list for quarter 2 shortly.

See Comments

Spam problem

by compasssion | updated 2 hours ago

6 | 39 comments | [+]

HumorFunny Board Game Memes

by Board Game Halv | updated 35 days ago

29 | 30 comments | [+]

Worker Placement As A Life Action Philosophy

by WadeB1977 | updated 6 days ago

27 | 22 comments | [+]

Pass/Missed/Perfect - World Series of Board Gaming Lineup

by Atlas | updated 4 months ago

23 | 30 comments | [+]

My Top 50 Games 2021

by Skurvy5 | updated 48 days ago

22 | 39 comments | [+]

Hello to all! Is that wonderful time of year again when one has an opportunity to sit back and reflect and make board game lists! Last year I did a Top 20 but this year my collection has grown to the point where I can now confidently do a Top 50 list. Where possible I'll note how games have shifted from last year and at the end I'll discuss a few games that I haven't played yet that probably could push their way into the top 50. I'll do this list from great to most great.

50.#Everdell (Last year 14) Fun game, but for various reasons I traded this one away.

49.#Kingdom Builder Fast playing, lighter game that I enjoy playing with my daughters.

48.#Aeon's End: Legacy (Last year 18) Was a great experience but as a true legacy game there isn't much use for the box at this point. Yes, I guess I could play one off games with the legacy content but too many games, too little time.

47.#7 Wonders Duel A fun and surprisingly crunchy 2 player game. I just recently traded this one away as it unfortunately just never hit my table.

46.#CloudAge A good not great Pfister with a really cool theme and some cool ideas but manages to somehow not last long enough and yet is also too long at the same time.

45.#Dwellings of Eldervale I had enormous hopes for this one. And while it does have some awesome ideas, and is a pretty good solo game, at the end of the day it is less than the sum of its parts. Used this one as trade fodder and picked up some good value for trading it away.

44.#Trajan (last year 22) A fun Feld game with some cool mechanics that just doesn't hit the table as much as I'd like. I'm a sucker for Roman history so even though the theme is hardly there I seem to give it a bit of extra credit for that theme.

43.#Dominion A classic game that languishes at the bottom of my Kallax. Would play it a lot more if it had a solo mode or something.

42.#High Frontier 4 All I acquired this game shortly after Christmas last year and was so so excited to get it. There is so much good in this box. I love the map - it's an absolutely stunning depiction of our solar system. I love the simulation of orbital mechanics. I love the usage of realistic future tech. But as a game? It just doesn't quite all add up. I ended up using my copy as part of trade.

41.#Scythe (last year 16) A fantastic production with fantastic components and all kinds of fun in the box. But after loads of plays I ended up feeling like I was done with this game. The campaign from Rise of Fenris was fantastic. Ended up trading this one for Dwellings which then got traded for a bunch of other games.

40.#The Lord of the Rings: Journeys in Middle-earth Another fantastic box of fun with great components. I wanted to like this one more than I did. Lots of cool in this package but at the end of the day it just had enough nagging little problems that I felt confident enough to trade it away. I think my biggest problem with this one is that the campaign didn't allow you enough time to explore all these cool locations. Lots of pressure to always push forward faster and faster. Also constantly shuffling those little cards got a bit old.

39.#Dune: Imperium This is a great game! It's a deck builder combined with a worker placement and area conflict game! And... I wish it focused more on one single mechanism. The deck building is fun, but the game is too short to really dig into the deck building. The worker placement is cool - but there isn't enough meat there. The area conflict is exciting! But there is only one space to fight over. I ended up trading this one away for great value.

38.#Underwater Cities (last year 9) Huge drop for this one. It's still a great game with an awesome theme. I would gladly play this any time. But I ended up getting a similar game from the same designer that pushed this one down.

37.#Terraforming Mars: Ares Expedition Recent addition to my collection. It's an interesting combination of regular TM and Race for the Galaxy. Right now I still like both "parent" games more but this one is one to watch. I definitely appreciate the high component quality in this one.

36.#Empires of the Void II (last year 19) A fantastic game with some of the most beautiful artwork in my collection. This one is pushed down a bit simply because I just don't get it to the table very often. It's very good though.

35.#Maracaibo (last year 13) A fantastic Pfister that got pushed down by a different Pfister game that you'll see further up on the list. A lot to love in this game, especially the cool legacy style story, but also quite fiddly to set up.

34.#Neom: Create the City of Tomorrow.A fun and light city building game that I never hear anyone talk about. Some cool ideas in a nice package.

33.#Civilization: A New Dawn I absolutely love the Civ PC games and this is a surprising cool board game adaptation. I love the action selection mechanism in this one which is surprisingly underutilized across the hobby. I really would like to grab the expansion for this one.

32.#Viscounts of the West KingdomRelatively new add to my collection and I'm still getting into this one. I love the deck building and interesting decisions in this one. Fantastic solo mode too. Look for this one to climb in the future with additional plays.

31.#Oath: Chronicles of Empire and Exile Picked this one up over the summer. It's definitely unique and has lots of cool ideas. It's a beast to learn but is incredibly thematic and intense. Not sure if I should keep it in my collection as it's not really a solo game and I doubt I can get my game group to play it. It's fantastic though.

30.#First Martians: Adventures on the Red Planet (last year 10) I love the theme in this one and it tells cool stories. Just haven't played it as much in the last year and it's been pushed down by other games.

29.#SpaceCorp One of the 3 big "build a space program games" - the other two being High frontier and Stellar Horizons- and SpaceCorps is easily the most euro-style of those games. Definitely more of an abstracted game than High Frontier and probably more fun because of that fact. But also less realistic.

28.#Root (Last year 15) This one has been pushed down because I simply hadn't gotten it to the table very much. However I recently acquired the#Root: The Clockwork Expansion which makes me much more likely to play this game. I'm looking forward to playing this one a lot more this coming year.

27.#Black Angel Absolutely gorgeous game - artwork by Ian O'Toole - with some really interesting dice placement mechanics. I haven't played this one as much as I would like.

26.#Circadians: First Light (last year 8) Really great game that has simply been pushed down the list by even greater games. Has a phenomenal solo mode. I really should play this one more.

25.#Wingspan (last year 21) Beautiful game with a unique theme. Really enjoy playing this one with my daughter. Decent solo mode, phenomenal components.

24.#Hallertau A really strong Uwe game with great card play. Lighter than some other Uwe games and has a nice beat your own solo mode. Great for a lazy Sunday afternoon.

23.#Xia: Legends of a Drift System A grail game of mine for a long time and I can't believe it isn't in the top 10. Just haven't played it enough to push some of the other games down. Really fun space exploration game with all kinds of cool ships and is extremely thematic.

22.#Praga Caput Regni This is the game that replaced#Underwater Cities for me. A really cool theme with lots of fun euro content. Love the art work in this one too.

21.#Tawantinsuyu: The Inca Empire The first of many games that features a David Turzci solo design. This game is just a wonderful euro game with crunchy decisions to make every single turn. A little more thematic than you'd expect, but not really.

20.#Paladins of the West Kingdom(last year 11) - my current favorite of the West Kingdom games. Love the interconnected tracks and the various buildings and round goals. Very fun. Strong solo mode.

19.#Tapestry As "So Very Wrong About Games" so appropriately described: this game is tracks on tracks on tracks and it really speaks to me and my game group. A small amount of theme but surprisingly fun with a great solo mode to boot. Wish the miniatures looked better though.

18.#Barrage A cutthroat Euro Game about water management with a fantastic solo AI and some really cool mechanics. File this one under "game I need to play more".

17.#Tekhenu: Obelisk of the SunOne of the mighty "T" games with a delicious solo mode from David Turzci. Cool theme with this game and I enjoy the multiple mechanisms in this one.

16.#Leaving Earth Absolutely love this game. A realistic space game with involved mission planning and lots of brain burning decisions. The expansions really add a lot to this game and wow it's fun.

15.#Great Western Trail (Second Edition)

Wow! This is by far the best Pfister I've ever played. It blows Maracaibo and CloudAge out of the water. Meaningful deck building with amazing components and a unique theme. Amazing.

14.#Kanban EV. Starting to hit some really amazing games here. Phenomenal components, beautiful artwork, awesome theme, and a fantastic David Turzci solo mode.

13.#Middara: Unintentional Malum – Act 1. Woah. This is a game. Tons and tons of content, incredibly flexible and open ended character development. Lots and lots of dice. Great story. Haven't finished the campaign yet and had to pack it away to make some space to play other games.

12.#Hadrian's Wall

One of the only roll and writes I've ever played and what a game. I love all the interconnection between the various parts. It's an amazing solo game and really gives you a fantastic since of progress.

11.#Imperium: Classics

An incredibly thematic deck-builder with a crazy variety of play styles to pick from. Particularly great solo mode designed by - who else - David Turzci. Lots to explore in this game and I feel like I've barely scratched the surface.

10.#Star Wars Imperial Assault

Last year this was ranked number 5. Still one of my most favorite games of all time. Suffers from a lack of recent play time but really enjoy everything about this one. Really great Star Wars flavor and a ton of content. Great solo too, either with the app or using a fan-made variant.

9.#On Mars

Huge, sprawling, deep. Complex. Phenomenal. It's OK solo but really shined with my game group. We had a blast and can't wait to table it again.

8. #Race for the Galaxy

Deep, but not complex. Huge variety, but not overwhelming. A quick playing solo game with endless amounts of variety. I have finally introduced it to my game group too so I'm looking forward to many more plays multiplayer. Gathering Storm expansion is very high up on my "required" expansions list.

7.#Gloomhaven

Last year this was #4. I still love this to bits but it's been a while since I tabled it. I did play the digital adaptation which is amazing with my friends a couple of times and the card play is simply unmatched with this one. Truly a great box of fun.

6.#A Feast for Odin

Last year this was also ranked in the 6 spot. I haven't played all of Mr. Rosenberg's games but this is by far my favorite. The wide-open action board combines so beautifully with the polyomino system. The mild dice roll elements add just a little bit of randomness to the game. I doubt I will ever get to play this game enough to see all of the cards. Truly a great game.

5.#Gaia Project

Last year this was ranked number 3 overall. I still love this game so so much. The engine building and asymmetric factions combine for almost endless combinations of strategy. Also features one of the best non-David Turzci solo modes I've seen. Simple yet challenging. A great game all around.

4.#Terraforming Mars

Last year this was ranked 7th overall. I did get a fair few plays of this one this year, including adding in Venus Next, Colonies, and very recently Turmoil expansions. There is so much to love in this game, especially once you get used to the uneven card art and average component quality. I know it is a bit much asking folks to get past the art but if you ever find it within yourself to give this one a try I know you won't be disappointed.

3.#Mage Knight: Ultimate Edition

Last year this was ranked 2nd overall. I really need to play this one again. So many games, not enough time. This is an epic, amazing game. I can't say enough good things about this game. Still my absolute favorite solo game, even though it hasn't hit the table recently. I also honestly don't think the rule book is that terrible. Is it great? No, but there are so many other aids to help you learn the game at this point that rule book complaints shouldn't be used as excuses any more.

2.#Star Wars: Rebellion

Shocker! My number one game has been dethroned. I love love love this game but it is a beast to table. My good friend who plays this with me every year has been unable to come out to Minnesota for the last 2 years due to Covid restrictions and I have been sorely missing my plays of this great game. Really love everything about this game though.

1.#Anachrony: Infinity Box

A game great enough to unseat Rebellion. I initially picked up just the essentials edition of this game and fell in love immediately. After my first solo play I knew that I had to get all of the content for this game. I managed to snag the Infinity Box and WOW is this game great. An unbelievable solo AI designed by, of course, David Turzci, crazy amounts of modules to add in or take out, and incredibly thematic euro-style gameplay. What more can I say about this one? It's incredible.

So that's my list! 50 great games. I do have quite the list of games that I need to play (listed in no particular order):

#Bonfire

#Brass: Birmingham

#Pipeline

#Falling Sky: The Gallic Revolt Against Caesar

#Kepler-3042

#Stellar Horizons

#Space Empires 4X

#Martians: A Story of Civilization

#The Lord of the Rings: The Card Game

#Founders of Gloomhaven

#MicroMacro: Crime City